Alternative ways to support formal education

Dear all,

This main topic introduces you to organizational models of distance education to support formal education both at primary and secondary level. It defines what we mean by 'alternative ways to support formal education', identifies some related issues, refers to some case studies, and lists some of the important references.

Definition

Alternative ways to support formal education is a form of supporting classroom teaching by using alternative organizational models and media which can be classified as distance education. It is generally part of the formal education system.

Issues and questions

The question may be raised if the use of media in classroom teaching can be classified as distance education (go back to Keegan's definition of distance education). You need to study the some of the case studies below to form your opinion.

Consider the below cases and ask how the media, the audience and the organizational models fit together.

Case studies

Interactive Radio Instruction IRI (Latin America, Africa): Using Radio to teach; allows to provide quality instruction with less qualified teachers, whose role is facilitation rather than instruction -learning: the impact of ICT on distance education.

Original series  => Subsequent series
Nicaragua Math       => Thai Math; Bolivia Math 1-2; Haiti Math  2-4; Guinea Math
Kenya English   => Lesotho English ; South Africa English; PALOP Portuguese; Costa Rica English/Teacher Training
Honduras => El Salvador Math; Dom. Rep. Math
Early childhood development => Bolivia ECD; Nepal ECD, Ecuador Critical Thinking Skills (the Bolivian series is also used in areas as Ecuador; Columbia; Honduras)
Source:  Techknowlogia



IRI in South Africa

The South African IRI was implemented in 1992 by the Open Learning Systems Educational Trust (OLSET), an NGO, based in Johannesburg. Initially the USAID provided the funds and LearnTech provided the technical support. Currently funding for the running of the programme comes from foreign donors, the main source being Norwegian aids. The audience of the South African IRI programme comprises of Black children in Grade 1, 2, and 3 of primary schools. The programme provides daily, half-hour English lessons, either through radio broadcasts, or through recorded cassettes, to grade 1, 2, and 3 classrooms of Black primary schools. The teachers also receive support and training on IRI methodology through a network of co-ordinators. The original design was based on the early IRI model pioneered by the academics at Stanford University. Soon the curriculum and the instructional design changed according to the needs of democratic South Africa (Naidoo, 1998; Potter and Leigh, 1995). The programme tries to get more teacher involvement and more peer interaction among the learners.

(Edirisingha,1999, p. 4)

Sub-Saharan Africa: Study Centre
Many post-colonial African countries could not expand the conventional schools within their shrinking budgets, even within a generation or more (Perraton, 1982). They chose distance education as an alternative model, which was becoming popular in rich countries at that time. Study Centre model was the particular organisational structure that was established to provide education at a distance in three countries in Sub-Saharan Africa: Malawi, Zambia. Most students of these programmes are primary-school leavers working at junior secondary level. All the three countries use an approach which recognises that these students need considerable support and have combined the use of print correspondence materials with support from tutor. ‘The basic learning package is the same in the three countries. On enrolment students receive printed correspondence courses and access to a marking service. They then register in a local study centre (called an open secondary class in Zambia) where they meet every day. They are supervised by individuals who are either primary school teachers or reasonably well educated adults, and they may get the opportunity to listen to radio programmes or taped instruction (Curran and Murphy, 1992, p.19). The courses provided are equivalent to those of the regular school, and at the successful completion of the course the learners gain certificates that are comparable to those gained from formal schools. Learners study at the study centres, under the supervision of facilitators, using the print materials specially prepared for them. Radio and other audio-visual media are also used to some extent.

(Edirisingha,1999, p. 5)

Telesecundaria (Mexico): Uses Television to reduce the number of specialized subject teachers; allows to run cost-effective schools in rural areas and reduces urban migration (963000 students in 16000 schools). - The model has been replicated in other LA countries (e.g. Costa Rica).

The pedagogical model works similar to IRI. Subject matter presentation is left to the TV teacher while the classroom teacher takes the role of a facilitator and monitor.

Mexico: Telesecundaria

Telesecundaria is a programme for children’s education that has been running in Mexico since 1967. It is an out-of-school programme, providing the regular secondary curriculum, parallel to that of the seventh to ninth grades of secondary school. Students attend classes, and receive television lessons, about 30 hours a week, usually in premises provided by local authorities. Workbooks which students have to buy commercially back the television programmes. Co-ordinators, who are mainly primary school teachers, are employed to prepare the class for each broadcast and to help with students’ work and follow-up. They supervise the work of students in all three grades and in all subjects. They are supplied with a monthly outline of the ground to be covered in the television programmes and the workbooks. The quality of the broadcasts attracted criticism in the early years although studies showed that they were contributing significantly to student learning (Jamison et al, 1978: 218-21).

(Edirisingha,1999, p. 8)

Dominican Republic: Interactive Radio Instruction
This programme has been developed by the USAID, following early work in Nicaragua in 1974 and in Kenya in 1980. The aim was to provide a low cost alternative to traditional schooling (Helwig et al, 1999). The programme, named Radio Assisted Community Basic Education (RADECO) was implemented in the south-western region of the Dominican Republic in 1981, where at that time, in isolated mountains, one-fifth of the children of primary school age were deprived of education by poverty and distance (AID, n.d.). RADECO, started in 1981, is the longest living IRI project, which still broadcasts to rural communities in the southwestern region of the Dominican Republic. The students received non-formal short lessons in mathematics and Spanish that raised their test scores to approximately the same level as students in formal schools. The total population reached so far is now close to 140,000 (Helwig et al, 1999).
The RADECO students work all day in coffee or cane fields. In the afternoons they gather in a shelter that functions as the radio school where they listen to RADECO broadcasts. The broadcasts cover the core curriculum of the formal schools: literacy, numeracy, social studies, and natural science. They learn an hour each day, and they are learning it as well as their counterparts in traditional schools, who spend three or four times as many hours in their classrooms (A.I.D., n.d). The students are not required to wear a uniform, and in fact most parents cannot afford it. As one mother puts it: ‘what is important is that the children are taught. They are educated, without regard to material things.’ The shelters (enramada) are mostly thatched roofs on four support posts built from inexpensive local material.

(Edirisingha,1999, p. 8-9)

Literature

The borderline between alternative routes to formal education and nonformal education are not always clear cut. The NOS model (National Open Schools) are a point in case (cf. Dewal). They also could be classified here since they often offer 'alternative routes to formal education' to school drop outs. This is why Edirisingha (1999) remains a good starting point. Additionally, you should read some of the short introductory articles in TechKowlogia.
A central resource for this topic is still Perraton (1982).

I think this is a base from where you can start and those of you who want to specialize in this area may expand from here.

Kind regards
Thomas